Objectives Adjusting for potential confounders is crucial for producing valuable evidence in outcome studies. Although numerous studies have been published using the Korea National Health Insurance Claim Database, no study has critically reviewed the methods used to adjust for confounders. This study aimed to review these studies and suggest methods and applications to adjust for confounders.
Methods We conducted a literature search of electronic databases, including PubMed and Embase, from January 1, 2021 to December 31, 2022. In total, 278 studies were retrieved. Eligibility criteria were published in English and outcome studies. A literature search and article screening were independently performed by 2 authors and finally, 173 of 278 studies were included.
Results Thirty-nine studies used matching at the study design stage, and 171 adjusted for confounders using regression analysis or propensity scores at the analysis stage. Of these, 125 conducted regression analyses based on the study questions. Propensity score matching was the most common method involving propensity scores. A total of 171 studies included age and/or sex as confounders. Comorbidities and healthcare utilization, including medications and procedures, were used as confounders in 146 and 82 studies, respectively.
Conclusions This is the first review to address the methods and applications used to adjust for confounders in recently published studies. Our results indicate that all studies adjusted for confounders with appropriate study designs and statistical methodologies; however, a thorough understanding and careful application of confounding variables are required to avoid erroneous results.
Summary
Korean summary
건강보험청구자료를 사용한 성과연구에서는 교란요인 통제가 중요하다. 최근 발표된 연구들은
연구설계와 통계 분석 과정에 적절하게 교란요인을 통제하였다. 연구의 질을 높이기 위해서는 건강보험청구자료에서 수집 가능한 교란 요인에 대한 이해와 방법론적 가이드라인이 요구된다.
Key Message
All recently published studies using Health Insurance Claims Database adjusted for confounders with appropriate study designs and statistical methodologies.
The review suggests the need for careful application of confounding variables and the methodological guidance to improve the quality of outcome studies.
Objectives Measuring the quality of care is paramount to inform policies for healthcare services. Nevertheless, little is known about the quality of primary care and acute care provided in Korea. This study investigated trends in the quality of primary care and acute care.
Methods Case-fatality rates and avoidable hospitalization rates were used as performance indicators to assess the quality of primary care and acute care. Admission data for the period 2008 to 2020 were extracted from the National Health Insurance Claims Database. Case-fatality rates and avoidable hospitalization rates were standardized by age and sex to adjust for patients’ characteristics over time, and significant changes in the rates were identified by joinpoint regression.
Results The average annual percent change in age-/sex-standardized case-fatality rates for acute myocardial infarction was -2.3% (95% confidence interval, -4.6 to 0.0). For hemorrhagic and ischemic stroke, the age-/sex-standardized case-fatality rates were 21.8% and 5.9%, respectively in 2020; these rates decreased since 2008 (27.1 and 8.7%, respectively). The average annual percent change in age-/sex-standardized avoidable hospitalization rates ranged from -9.4% to -3.0%, with statistically significant changes between 2008 and 2020. In 2020, the avoidable hospitalization rates decreased considerably compared with the 2019 rate because of the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic.
Conclusions The avoidable hospitalization rates and case-fatality rates decreased overall during the past decade, but they were relatively high compared with other countries. Strengthening primary care is an essential requirement to improve patient health outcomes in the rapidly aging Korean population.
Summary
Korean summary
본 연구에서는 급성심근경색증과 뇌졸중 치명률, 외래진료 민감질환의 예방 가능한 입원율을 사용하여 한국의 의료 질 수준을 분석하였다. 2008~2020년 동안 치명률과 예방 가능한 입원율은 감소하는 추세이다. 그러나, 예방 가능한 입원율은 다른 국가에 비해 상대적으로 높아 환자의 건강결과 향상을 위하여 일차의료 강화가 요구된다.
OBJECTIVES This study aims to compare quality indicators for the hemodialysis services between patients with health insurance and those with medical aid. METHODS: This study used data from sampled hospitals that provided a hemodialysis service. A total of 2287 patients were selected, and the information for hemodialysis service has been granted from medical record reviews. A multi-level regression analysis was used to examine the differences in process and outcome indicators for hemodialysis between patients with health insurance and those with medical aid. Process indicators were defined as: frequency of hemodialysis, hemodialysis time, erythropoietin (EPO) use, measurement of hemodialysis dose at least once a month, measurement of phosphate at least once every three months, and measurement of albumin at least once every three months. Outcome indicators were defined as: hemodialysis adequacy, anemia management, blood pressure management, and calcium, phosphate and nutrition management. The total scores for outcome indicators ranged from 0 (worst) to 4 (best). RESULTS: There was a significant difference in the measurement of hemodialysis dose at least once a month between patients with health insurance and those with medical aid (OR 0.66, 95% CI=0.43-0.99). However, frequency of hemodialysis, hemodialysis time, EPO use, measurement of phosphate at least once every three months, measurement of albumin at least once every three months, hemodialysis adequacy management, Hb> or =11 g/dL, blood pressure within the range of 100-140/60-90 mmHg, calcium x phosphate< or =55 g2/dL2 and albumin> or =4 g/dL were not significantly different between the groups. CONCLUSIONS: There were no significant differences in outcome indicators for hemodialysis between the groups. Further studies are warranted into the mechanism that results in no differences in the outcome indicators for hemodialysis.
Summary
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
A Study of Effect on the Smoking Status using Multilevel Logistic Model Ji Hye Lee, Tae-Young Heo Korean Journal of Applied Statistics.2014; 27(1): 89. CrossRef
Multilevel Analysis on Factors Influencing Death and Transfer in Inpatient with Severe Injury Young Eun Choi, Kang Suk Lee Health Policy and Management.2013; 23(3): 233. CrossRef
Factors Affecting Diabetic Screening Behavior of Korean Adults: A Multilevel Analysis Hyeongsu Kim, Minjung Lee, Haejoon Kim, Kunsei Lee, Sounghoon Chang, Vitna Kim, Jun Pyo Myong, Soyoun Jeon Asian Nursing Research.2013; 7(2): 67. CrossRef
OBJECTIVES To examine the prophylactic antibiotic use in reducing surgical site infection. METHODS: This was a retrospective study for patients aged 18 years and older who underwent gastrectomy, cholecystectomy, colectomy, cesarean section and hysterectomy. The data source was quality assessment data of the Health Insurance Review & Assessment Service gathered from medical records of 302 national hospitals. Prophylactic antibiotic use was defined as: timely antibiotic administration or inappropriate antibiotic selection. We performed hierarchical logistic regression to examine the association between prophylactic antibiotic use and surgical site infection with adjustment for covariates. RESULTS: The study population consisted of 16 348 patients (1588 gastrectomies, 2327 cholecystectomies, 1,384 colectomies, 3977 hysterectomies and 7072 cesarean sections) and surgical site infection was identified in 351 (2.1%) patients. The rates of timely antibiotic administration and inappropriate antibiotic selection varied according to procedures. Cholecystectomy patients who received timely prophylactic antibiotic had a significantly reduced risk of surgical site infection compared with those who did not receive a timely prophylactic antibiotics (OR 0.64, 95% CI=0.50-0.83), but no significant reduction was observed for other procedures. When inappropriate prophylactic antibiotics were given, the risk of surgical site infection significantly increased: 8.26-fold (95% CI=4.34-15.7) for gastrectomy, 4.73-fold (95% CI=2.09-10.7) for colectomy, 2.34-fold (95% CI=1.14-4.80) for cesarean section, 4.03-fold (95% CI=1.93-8.42) for hysterectomy. CONCLUSIONS: This study examines the association among timely antibiotic administration, inappropriate antibiotic selection and surgical site infection. Patients who received timely and appropriate antibiotics had a decreased risk of surgical site infection. Efforts to improve the timing of antibiotic administration and use of appropriate antibiotic are needed to lower the risk of surgical site infection.
Summary
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
The effect of first- and third-generation prophylactic antibiotics on hospitalization and medical expenditures for cardiac surgery Sung-Jin Bae, Inah Kim, Jaechul Song, Euy-Suk Chung Journal of Cardiothoracic Surgery.2022;[Epub] CrossRef
Incidence and Risk Factors of Wound Infection in Women Who Underwent Cesarean Section in 2014 at King Abdulaziz Medical City, Jeddah Roaa Gadeer , Nada Y Baatiah, Nourah Alageel, Mohammed Khaled Cureus.2020;[Epub] CrossRef
Pay-for-performance reduces healthcare spending and improves quality of care: Analysis of target and non-target obstetrics and gynecology surgeries Seung Ju Kim, Kyu-Tae Han, Sun Jung Kim, Eun-Cheol Park International Journal for Quality in Health Care.2017; 29(2): 222. CrossRef
Comparing the Postoperative Complications, Hospitalization Days and Treatment Expenses Depending on the Administration of Postoperative Prophylactic Antibiotics to Hysterectomy Mi Young Jung, Kyung-Yeon Park Korean Journal of Women Health Nursing.2017; 23(1): 42. CrossRef
Risk Factors for Surgical Site Infections According to Electronic Medical Records Data Young Hee Kim, Young-Hee Yom Journal of Korean Academy of Fundamentals of Nursing.2014; 21(2): 151. CrossRef
Morbidity and risk factors for surgical site infection following cesarean section in Guangdong Province, China Shi‐Peng Gong, Hong‐Xia Guo, Hong‐Zhen Zhou, Li Chen, Yan‐Hong Yu Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology Research.2012; 38(3): 509. CrossRef
Overview of Antibiotic Use in Korea Baek-Nam Kim Infection & Chemotherapy.2012; 44(4): 250. CrossRef
The effect of surgical site infection on the length of stay and health care costs Jin-Hee Chang, Kyoung-Hoon Kim, Soon-Man Kwon, Seon-A Yeom, Choon-Seon Park Korean Journal of Health Policy and Administration.2011; 21(1): 44. CrossRef
Risk factors for surgical site infection in children at the teaching hospital Gabriel Touré, Bamako A. Togo, Y. Coulibaly, B.T. Dembélé, B. Togo, M. Keita, L. Kanté, A. Traoré, I. Diakité, H. Ouologuem, G. Diallo Journal of Hospital Infection.2011; 79(4): 371. CrossRef
The Feasibility of Short Term Prophylactic Antibiotics in Gastric Cancer Surgery Jun Suh Lee, Han Hong Lee, Kyo Young Song, Cho Hyun Park, Hae Myung Jeon Journal of Gastric Cancer.2010; 10(4): 206. CrossRef
OBJECTIVES To compare the performance of three International Statistical Classification of Diseases, 10th Revision translations of the Charlson comorbidities when predicting in-hospital among patients with myocardial infarction (MI). METHODS: MI patients > or =20 years of age with the first admission during 2006 were identified(n=20,280). Charlson comorbidities were drawn from Heath Insurance Claims Data managed by Health Insurance Review and Assessment Service in Korea. Comparisions for various conditions included (a) three algorithms (Halfon, Sundararajan, and Quan algorithms), (b) lookback periods (1-, 3- and 5-years), (c) data range (admission data, admission and ambulatory data), and (d) diagnosis range (primary diagnosis and first secondary diagnoses, all diagnoses). The performance of each procedure was measured with the c-statistic derived from multiple logistic regression adjusted for age, sex, admission type and Charlson comorbidity index. A bootstrapping procedure was done to determine the approximate 95% confidence interval. RESULTS: Among the 20,280 patients, the mean age was 63.3 years, 67.8% were men and 7.1% died while hospitalized. The Quan and Sundararajan algorithms produced higher prevalences than the Halfon algorithm. The c-statistic of the Quan algorithm was slightly higher, but not significantly different, than that of other two algorithms under all conditions. There was no evidence that on longer lookback periods, additional data, and diagnoses improved the predictive ability. CONCLUSIONS: In health services study of MI patients using Health Insurance Claims Data, the present results suggest that the Quan Algorithm using a 1-year lookback involving primary diagnosis and the first secondary diagnosis is adequate in predicting in-hospital mortality.
Summary
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Increased Risk of Myocardial Infarction, Heart Failure, and Atrial Fibrillation After Spinal Cord Injury Jung Eun Yoo, Miso Kim, Bongseong Kim, Heesun Lee, Won Hyuk Chang, Jeehyun Yoo, Kyungdo Han, Dong Wook Shin Journal of the American College of Cardiology.2024; 83(7): 741. CrossRef
Impact of anemia requiring transfusion or erythropoiesis-stimulating agents on new-onset cardiovascular events and mortality after continuous renal replacement therapy Junseok Jeon, Danbee Kang, Hyejeong Park, Kyungho Lee, Jung Eun Lee, Wooseong Huh, Juhee Cho, Hye Ryoun Jang Scientific Reports.2024;[Epub] CrossRef
Adjusting for Confounders in Outcome Studies Using the Korea National Health Insurance Claim Database: A Review of Methods and Applications Seung Jin Han, Kyoung Hoon Kim Journal of Preventive Medicine and Public Health.2024; 57(1): 1. CrossRef
Risk of Parkinson disease in stroke patients: A nationwide cohort study in South Korea Hea Lim Choi, Jong Hyeon Ahn, Won Hyuk Chang, Wonyoung Jung, Bong Sung Kim, Kyungdo Han, Jinyoung Youn, Dong Wook Shin European Journal of Neurology.2024;[Epub] CrossRef
Risk of fracture among patients with spinal cord injury: A nationwide cohort study in South Korea Seonghye Kim, Bongseong Kim, Kyung-Do Han, Junhee Park, Jung Eun Yoo, Hea Lim Choi, Won Hyuk Chang, In Young Cho, Dong Wook Shin Bone.2024; 183: 117093. CrossRef
Increased end-stage renal disease risk in age-related macular degeneration: a nationwide cohort study with 10-year follow-up Wonyoung Jung, Junhee Park, Hye Ryoun Jang, Junseok Jeon, Kyungdo Han, Bongseong Kim, Je Moon Yoon, Dong Hui Lim, Dong Wook Shin Scientific Reports.2023;[Epub] CrossRef
Increased Risk of Developing Depression in Disability after Stroke: A Korean Nationwide Study Hea Lim Choi, Kyojin Yang, Kyungdo Han, Bongsung Kim, Won Hyuk Chang, Soonwook Kwon, Wonyoung Jung, Jung Eun Yoo, Hong Jin Jeon, Dong Wook Shin International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health.2023; 20(1): 842. CrossRef
Restless leg syndrome and risk of all-cause dementia: a nationwide retrospective cohort study Keun You Kim, Eun Hwa Kim, Myeongjee Lee, Junghee Ha, Inkyung Jung, Eosu Kim Alzheimer's Research & Therapy.2023;[Epub] CrossRef
Prognostic significance of albuminuria in elderly of various ages with diabetes Subin Hwang, Kyungho Lee, Jeeeun Park, Do Hee Kim, Junseok Jeon, Hye Ryoun Jang, Kyu Yeon Hur, Jae Hyeon Kim, Wooseong Huh, Yoon-Goo Kim, Jung Eun Lee Scientific Reports.2023;[Epub] CrossRef
The Impact of Clinical Prognosis of Viral Hepatitis in Head and Neck Cancer Patients Receiving Concurrent Chemoradiotherapy Yu-Ming Wang, Sheng-Dean Luo, Ching-Nung Wu, Shao-Chun Wu, Wei-Chih Chen, Yao-Hsu Yang, Tai-Jan Chiu Biomedicines.2023; 11(11): 2946. CrossRef
Pulmonary Tuberculosis and the Incidence of Lung Cancer among Patients with Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Hye Yun Park, Danbee Kang, Sun Hye Shin, Hayoung Choi, Seung Hun Jang, Chang-Hoon Lee, Hojoong Kim, O. Jung Kwon, Chin Kook Rhee, Juhee Cho Annals of the American Thoracic Society.2022; 19(4): 640. CrossRef
Economic burden attributable to Clostridioides difficile infections in South Korea: a nationwide propensity score-matched study K.J. Son, Y.A. Kim, Y.S. Park Journal of Hospital Infection.2022; 120: 1. CrossRef
Association between the presence of delirium during intensive care unit admission and cognitive impairment or psychiatric problems: the Korean ICU National Data Study Ryoung-Eun Ko, Danbee Kang, Hyejung Park, Juhee Cho, Gee Young Suh, Chi Ryang Chung Journal of Intensive Care.2022;[Epub] CrossRef
Impact of Renal Replacement Therapy on Mortality and Renal Outcomes in Critically Ill Patients with Acute Kidney Injury: A Population-Based Cohort Study in Korea between 2008 and 2015 Subin Hwang, Danbee Kang, Hyejeong Park, Youngha Kim, Eliseo Guallar, Junseok Jeon, Jung-Eun Lee, Wooseong Huh, Gee-Young Suh, Juhee Cho, Hye-Ryoun Jang Journal of Clinical Medicine.2022; 11(9): 2392. CrossRef
Application of the New Preoperative Frailty Risk Score in Elderly Patients Undergoing Emergency Surgery Sang-Wook Lee, Keon-Sik Kim, Sung-Wook Park, Jaewon Kim, Jeong-Hyun Choi, Sangho Lee, Kyoung-Woon Joung, In-Cheol Choi Gerontology.2022; 68(11): 1276. CrossRef
Risk Factors of Incident Lung Cancer in Patients with Non-Cystic Fibrosis Bronchiectasis: A Korean Population-Based Study Youlim Kim, Kyungdo Han, Juhwan Yoo, Hyung Koo Kang, Tai Sun Park, Dong Won Park, Ji Young Hong, Ji-Yong Moon, Sang-Heon Kim, Tae Hyung Kim, Kwang Ha Yoo, Jang Won Sohn, Ho Joo Yoon, Hayoung Choi, Hyun Lee Cancers.2022; 14(11): 2604. CrossRef
Recent Increases in Influenza-Related Hospitalizations, Critical Care Resource Use, and In-Hospital Mortality: A 10-Year Population-Based Study in South Korea Tae Hwa Hong, Hyung Seok Lee, Nam-Eun Kim, Kyu Jin Lee, Yong Kyun Kim, Jung Nam An, Joo-Hee Kim, Hyung Won Kim, Sunghoon Park Journal of Clinical Medicine.2022; 11(16): 4911. CrossRef
Non–Cystic Fibrosis Bronchiectasis Increases the Risk of Lung Cancer Independent of Smoking Status Hayoung Choi, Hye Yun Park, Kyungdo Han, Juhwan Yoo, Sun Hye Shin, Bumhee Yang, Youlim Kim, Tai Sun Park, Dong Won Park, Ji-Yong Moon, Seung Won Ra, Sang-Heon Kim, Tae-Hyung Kim, Yeon-Mok Oh, Ho Joo Yoon, Jang Won Sohn, Hyun Lee Annals of the American Thoracic Society.2022; 19(9): 1551. CrossRef
Investigation of the Relationship between Psychiatry Visit and Suicide after Deliberate Self-Harm: A Longitudinal National Cohort Study (Preprint) Hye Hyeon Kim, Chanyoung Ko, Ji Ae Park, In Han Song, Yu Rang Park JMIR Public Health and Surveillance.2022;[Epub] CrossRef
Association between Age-Related Macular Degeneration and the Risk of Diabetes Mellitus: A Nationwide Cohort Study Wonyoung Jung, Je Moon Yoon, Kyungdo Han, Bongseong Kim, Sungsoon Hwang, Dong Hui Lim, Dong Wook Shin Biomedicines.2022; 10(10): 2435. CrossRef
A Study on The Efficacy of Vaccination in Elderly Patients with Breakthrough COVID-19 Infection Soobok Choi, Zion Choi, Chul-Min Ha, Hyoung-Ju Lee, Chong myung Kim Korean Journal of Clinical Geriatrics.2022; 23(2): 115. CrossRef
Glaucoma Surgery and Subsequent Retinal Vessel Occlusion Incidence in Elderly Patients: A Population-based Preliminary Study Yun Jeong Lee, Kyeong Ik Na, Young Kook Kim Journal of the Korean Glaucoma Society.2022; 11(2): 102. CrossRef
The risk of stroke according to statin medication compliance in older people with chronic periodontitis: an analysis using the Korea National Health Insurance Service-Senior Cohort Database Seon-Rye Kim, Minkook Son, Yu-Rin Kim Epidemiology and Health.2022; 44: e2022055. CrossRef
Impact of comorbidity burden on mortality in patients with COVID-19 using the Korean health insurance database Soo Ick Cho, Susie Yoon, Ho-Jin Lee Scientific Reports.2021;[Epub] CrossRef
The Relationship between Unmet Healthcare Needs Due to Financial Reasons and the Experience of Catastrophic Health Expenditures Jeong-Hee Kang, Chul-Woung Kim Journal of Korean Academy of Community Health Nursing.2021; 32(1): 95. CrossRef
Deep Spinal Infection after Outpatient Epidural Injections for Pain: A Retrospective Sample Cohort Study Using a Claims Database in South Korea Chang-Soon Lee, Young Jae Park, Jee Youn Moon, Yong-Chul Kim Anesthesiology.2021; 134(6): 925. CrossRef
Travel time to emergency care not by geographic time, but by optimal time: A nationwide cross-sectional study for establishing optimal hospital access time to emergency medical care in South Korea Won Mo Jang, Juyeon Lee, Sang Jun Eun, Jun Yim, Yoon Kim, Mi Young Kwak, M. Mahmud Khan PLOS ONE.2021; 16(5): e0251116. CrossRef
Evaluation of the Prognosis of COVID-19 Patients According to the Presence of Underlying Diseases and Drug Treatment Ejin Kim, Yong Chul Kim, Jae Yoon Park, Jiyun Jung, Jung Pyo Lee, Ho Kim International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health.2021; 18(10): 5342. CrossRef
Prior antiviral treatment and mortality among patients with hepatitis C virus-related hepatocellular carcinoma: A national cohort study Dong Hyun Sinn, Danbee Kang, Yun Soo Hong, Kwang Cheol Koh, Eliseo Guallar, Juhee Cho, Geum-Youn Gwak, Luca Rinaldi PLOS ONE.2021; 16(8): e0255624. CrossRef
Prognostic Factors of Renal Outcomes after Heart Transplantation: A Nationwide Retrospective Study Junseok Jeon, Hyejeong Park, Youngha Kim, Danbee Kang, Jung Eun Lee, Wooseong Huh, Eliseo Guallar, Juhee Cho, Hye Ryoun Jang Journal of Clinical Medicine.2021; 10(21): 5110. CrossRef
Impact of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease on mortality: A large national cohort study Hye Yun Park, Danbee Kang, Hyun Lee, Sun Hye Shin, Minwoong Kang, Sunga Kong, Chin Kook Rhee, Juhee Cho, Kwang Ha Yoo Respirology.2020; 25(7): 726. CrossRef
Post‐intensive care unit depression among critical care survivors: A nationwide population‐based study Jiyeon Kang, Seonyoung Yun, Young Shin Cho, Yeon Jin Jeong Japan Journal of Nursing Science.2020;[Epub] CrossRef
Identification of herpes zoster high‐risk group using Charlson comorbidity index: A nationwide retrospective cohort study Soo Ick Cho, Dong Hun Lee, Young Min Park The Journal of Dermatology.2020; 47(1): 47. CrossRef
Effect of anesthetic method on incidence of delirium after total hip replacement arthroplasty in South Korea: a population-based study using National Health Insurance claims data Eun-Ji Choi, Yoon Ji Choi, Sang Won Lee, Yun-Mi Choi, Hyun-Su Ri, Ju Yeon Park, Soon Ji Park, Jung-Min Son, Yoon Sook Lee Korean Journal of Anesthesiology.2020; 73(1): 36. CrossRef
Use of Gadoxetic Acid–enhanced Liver MRI and Mortality in More than 30 000 Patients with Hepatocellular Carcinoma: A Nationwide Analysis Tae Wook Kang, Sun-Young Kong, Danbee Kang, Min Woong Kang, Young Kon Kim, Seong Hyun Kim, Dong Hyun Sinn, Young Ae Kim, Kui Son Choi, Eun Sook Lee, Sang Myung Woo, Joung Hwan Back, Eliseo Guallar, Juhee Cho Radiology.2020; 295(1): 114. CrossRef
Relationship between Use of Rehabilitation Resources and ICU Readmission and ER Visits in ICU Survivors: the Korean ICU National Data Study 2008-2015 Yun Hee Park, Ryoung-Eun Ko, Danbee Kang, Jinkyeong Park, Kyeongman Jeon, Jeong Hoon Yang, Chi-Min Park, Joongbum Cho, Young Sook Park, Hyejung Park, Juhee Cho, Eliseo Guallar, Gee Young Suh, Chi Ryang Chung Journal of Korean Medical Science.2020;[Epub] CrossRef
Incidence of extrahepatic cancers among individuals with chronic hepatitis B or C virus infection: A nationwide cohort study Chai Yeong Hong, Dong Hyun Sinn, Danbee Kang, Seung Woon Paik, Eliseo Guallar, Juhee Cho, Geum‐Youn Gwak Journal of Viral Hepatitis.2020; 27(9): 896. CrossRef
Association between oral health and incidence of pneumonia: a population-based cohort study from Korea Minkook Son, Sangyong Jo, Ji Sung Lee, Dong Hyun Lee Scientific Reports.2020;[Epub] CrossRef
Association between hemoglobin variability and incidence of hypertension over 40 years: a Korean national cohort study Minkook Son, Junyong Park, Kyungil Park, Sung Yang Scientific Reports.2020;[Epub] CrossRef
Antidepressant adherence and its predictors in immigrants with depression Suhyun Jang, Hyemin Cho, Cinoo Kang, Sunmee Jang Medicine.2020; 99(51): e23308. CrossRef
Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation in Korea – Trends and impact of hospital volume on outcome: Analysis of national insurance data 2009–2014 Chee Kiang Tay, Yang Hyun Cho, Jinkyeong Park, Jeong Hoon Yang, Chi Ryang Chung, Kiick Sung, Juhee Cho, Danbee Kang, Hyejeong Park, Gee Young Suh Journal of Critical Care.2019; 49: 1. CrossRef
Association of statin therapy with clinical outcomes in patients with vasospastic angina: Data from Korean health insurance review and assessment service So Jin Park, Hyejeong Park, Danbee Kang, Taek Kyu Park, Jinkyeong Park, Joongbum Cho, Chi Ryang Chung, Kyeongman Jeon, Eliseo Guallar, Juhee Cho, Gee Young Suh, Jeong Hoon Yang, Raffaele Bugiardini PLOS ONE.2019; 14(1): e0210498. CrossRef
Factors influencing the incidence and treatment of intracranial aneurysm and subarachnoid hemorrhage: time trends and socioeconomic disparities under an universal healthcare system Won Kyung Lee, Chang Wan Oh, Heeyoung Lee, Kun Sei Lee, Hyeonseon Park Journal of NeuroInterventional Surgery.2019; 11(2): 159. CrossRef
Epidemiology of sepsis in Korea: a population-based study of incidence, mortality, cost and risk factors for death in sepsis Joonghee Kim, Kyuseok Kim, Heeyoung Lee, Soyeon Ahn Clinical and Experimental Emergency Medicine.2019; 6(1): 49. CrossRef
Changes in acute kidney injury epidemiology in critically ill patients: a population-based cohort study in Korea Subin Hwang, Hyejeong Park, Youngha Kim, Danbee Kang, Ho Suk Ku, Juhee Cho, Jung Eun Lee, Wooseong Huh, Eliseo Guallar, Gee Young Suh, Hye Ryoun Jang Annals of Intensive Care.2019;[Epub] CrossRef
Elderly Mortality and Exposure to Fine Particulate Matter and Ozone En-Joo Jung, Wonwoong Na, Kyung-Eun Lee, Jae-Yeon Jang Journal of Korean Medical Science.2019;[Epub] CrossRef
Association between long-term hemoglobin variability and mortality in Korean adults: a nationwide population-based cohort study Minkook Son, Sung Yang Scientific Reports.2019;[Epub] CrossRef
A nationwide analysis of intensive care unit admissions, 2009–2014 – The Korean ICU National Data (KIND) study Jinkyeong Park, Kyeongman Jeon, Chi Ryang Chung, Jeong Hoon Yang, Yang Hyun Cho, Joongbum Cho, Chi-Min Park, Hyejeong Park, Juhee Cho, Eliseo Guallar, Gee Young Suh Journal of Critical Care.2018; 44: 24. CrossRef
Incidence of Diabetes After Cancer Development Yul Hwangbo, Danbee Kang, Minwoong Kang, Saemina Kim, Eun Kyung Lee, Young Ae Kim, Yoon Jung Chang, Kui Son Choi, So-Youn Jung, Sang Myung Woo, Jin Seok Ahn, Sung Hoon Sim, Yun Soo Hong, Roberto Pastor-Barriuso, Eliseo Guallar, Eun Sook Lee, Sun-Young Kon JAMA Oncology.2018; 4(8): 1099. CrossRef
Differential prognosis of vasospastic angina according to presentation with sudden cardiac arrest or not: Analysis of the Korean Health Insurance Review and Assessment Service Taek Kyu Park, Hye Bin Gwag, So Jin Park, Hyejeong Park, Danbee Kang, Jinkyeong Park, Joongbum Cho, Chi Ryang Chung, Kyeongman Jeon, Gee Young Suh, Eliseo Guallar, Juhee Cho, Jeong Hoon Yang International Journal of Cardiology.2018; 273: 39. CrossRef
Incidence of Falls and Risk Factors of Falls in Inpatients Soo-Jin Yoon, Chun-Kyon Lee, In-Sun Jin, Jung-Gu Kang Quality Improvement in Health Care.2018; 24(2): 2. CrossRef
The Best Use of the Charlson Comorbidity Index With Electronic Health Care Database to Predict Mortality Aurélie Bannay, Christophe Chaignot, Pierre-Olivier Blotière, Mickaël Basson, Alain Weill, Philippe Ricordeau, François Alla Medical Care.2016; 54(2): 188. CrossRef
Comorbidity Adjustment in Health Insurance Claim Database Kyoung Hoon Kim Health Policy and Management.2016; 26(1): 71. CrossRef
A Convergence Study in the Severity-adjusted Mortality Ratio on inpatients with multiple chronic conditions Young-Suk Seo, Sung-Hong Kang Journal of Digital Convergence.2015; 13(12): 245. CrossRef
Development and validation of comorbidity index in South Korea S.-R. Kil, S.-I. Lee, Y.-H. Khang, M.-S. Lee, H.-J. Kim, S.-O. Kim, M.-W. Jo International Journal for Quality in Health Care.2012; 24(4): 391. CrossRef
OBJECTIVES To compare the performance of three comorbidity measurements (Charlson comorbidity index, Elixhauser's comorbidity and comorbidity selection) with the effect of different comorbidity lookback periods when predicting in-hospital mortality for patients who underwent percutaneous coronary intervention. METHODS: This was a retrospective study on patients aged 40 years and older who underwent percutaneous coronary intervention. To distinguish comorbidity from complications, the records of diagnosis were drawn from the National Health Insurance Database excluding diagnosis that admitted to the hospital. C-statistic values were used as measures for in comparing the predictability of comorbidity measures with lookback period, and a bootstrapping procedure with 1,000 replications was done to determine approximate 95% confidence interval. RESULTS: Of the 61,815 patients included in this study, the mean age was 63.3 years (standard deviation: +/-10.2) and 64.8% of the population was male. Among them, 1,598 (2.6%) had died in hospital. While the predictive ability of the Elixhauser s comorbidity and comorbidity selection was better than that of the Charlson comorbidity index, there was no significant difference among the three comorbidity measurements. Although the prevalence of comorbidity increased in 3 years of lookback periods, there was no significant improvement compared to 1 year of a lookback period. CONCLUSIONS: In a health outcome study for patients who underwent percutaneous coronary intervention using National Health Insurance Database, the Charlson comorbidity index was easy to apply without significant difference in predictability compared to the other methods. The one year of observation period was adequate to adjust the comorbidity. Further work to select adequate comorbidity measurements and lookback periods on other diseases and procedures are needed.
Summary
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Adjusting for Confounders in Outcome Studies Using the Korea National Health Insurance Claim Database: A Review of Methods and Applications Seung Jin Han, Kyoung Hoon Kim Journal of Preventive Medicine and Public Health.2024; 57(1): 1. CrossRef
High‐Intensity Statin Reduces the Risk of Mortality Among Chronic Liver Disease Patients With Atherosclerotic Cardiovascular Disease: A Population‐Based Cohort Study Sungho Bea, In‐Sun Oh, Ju Hwan Kim, Dong Hyun Sinn, Yoosoo Chang, Seungho Ryu, Ju‐Young Shin Journal of the American Heart Association.2023;[Epub] CrossRef
Impact of comorbidity assessment methods to predict non-cancer mortality risk in cancer patients: a retrospective observational study using the National Health Insurance Service claims-based data in Korea Sanghee Lee, Yoon Jung Chang, Hyunsoon Cho BMC Medical Research Methodology.2021;[Epub] CrossRef
Evaluating the impact of covariate lookback times on performance of patient-level prediction models Jill Hardin, Jenna M. Reps BMC Medical Research Methodology.2021;[Epub] CrossRef
Comorbidity and cervical cancer survival of Indigenous and non-Indigenous Australian women: A semi-national registry-based cohort study (2003-2012) Abbey Diaz, Peter D. Baade, Patricia C. Valery, Lisa J. Whop, Suzanne P. Moore, Joan Cunningham, Gail Garvey, Julia M. L. Brotherton, Dianne L. O’Connell, Karen Canfell, Diana Sarfati, David Roder, Elizabeth Buckley, John R. Condon, Stéphanie Filleur PLOS ONE.2018; 13(5): e0196764. CrossRef
Comorbidity Adjustment in Health Insurance Claim Database Kyoung Hoon Kim Health Policy and Management.2016; 26(1): 71. CrossRef
The Benefits Conferred by Radial Access for Cardiac Catheterization Are Offset by a Paradoxical Increase in the Rate of Vascular Access Site Complications With Femoral Access Lorenzo Azzalini, Kunle Tosin, Malorie Chabot-Blanchet, Robert Avram, Hung Q. Ly, Benoit Gaudet, Richard Gallo, Serge Doucet, Jean-François Tanguay, Réda Ibrahim, Jean C. Grégoire, Jacques Crépeau, Raoul Bonan, Pierre de Guise, Mohamed Nosair, Jean-Franço JACC: Cardiovascular Interventions.2015; 8(14): 1854. CrossRef
A Convergence Study in the Severity-adjusted Mortality Ratio on inpatients with multiple chronic conditions Young-Suk Seo, Sung-Hong Kang Journal of Digital Convergence.2015; 13(12): 245. CrossRef
Development and validation of comorbidity index in South Korea S.-R. Kil, S.-I. Lee, Y.-H. Khang, M.-S. Lee, H.-J. Kim, S.-O. Kim, M.-W. Jo International Journal for Quality in Health Care.2012; 24(4): 391. CrossRef
Development of Mortality Model of Severity-Adjustment Method of AMI Patients Ji-Hye Lim, Mun-Hee Nam Journal of the Korea Academia-Industrial cooperation Society.2012; 13(6): 2672. CrossRef
Use of hospitalisation history (lookback) to determine prevalence of chronic diseases: impact on modelling of risk factors for haemorrhage in pregnancy Jian Sheng Chen, Christine L Roberts, Judy M Simpson, Jane B Ford BMC Medical Research Methodology.2011;[Epub] CrossRef
The Impact of Medicaid Expansion to include population with low income on the preventable hospitalizations Hyun-Chul Shin, Se-Ra Kim Korean Journal of Health Policy and Administration.2010; 20(1): 87. CrossRef
Comparative Study on Three Algorithms of the ICD-10 Charlson Comorbidity Index with Myocardial Infarction Patients Kyoung Hoon Kim Journal of Preventive Medicine and Public Health.2010; 43(1): 42. CrossRef
OBJECTIVES We tried to evaluate the agreement of the Charlson comorbidity index values (CCI) obtained from different sources (medical records and National Health Insurance claims data) for gastric cancer patients. We also attempted to assess the prognostic value of these data for predicting 1-year mortality and length of the hospital stay (length of stay). METHODS: Medical records of 284 gastric cancer patients were reviewed, and their National Health Insurance claims data and death certificates were also investigated. To evaluate agreement, the kappa coefficient was tested. Multiple logistic regression analysis and multiple linear regression analysis were performed to evaluate and compare the prognostic power for predicting 1 year mortality and length of stay. RESULTS: The CCI values for each comorbid condition obtained from 2 different data sources appeared to poorly agree (kappa: 0.00-0.59). It was appeared that the CCI values based on both sources were not valid prognostic indicators of 1-year mortality. Only medical record-based CCI was a valid prognostic indicator of length of stay, even after adjustment of covariables (beta = 0.112, 95% CI = [0.017-1.267]). CONCLUSIONS: There was a discrepancy between the data sources with regard to the value of CCI both for the prognostic power and its direction. Therefore, assuming that medical records are the gold standard for the source for CCI measurement, claims data is not an appropriate source for determining the CCI, at least for gastric cancer.
Summary
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Factors Associated with Hospital Length of Stay among Women’s Cancer Patients: Based on the In-depth Injury Patient Surveillance System Data Yoonjung Kang, Hyewon Lee Journal of Health Informatics and Statistics.2022; 47(2): 148. CrossRef
The impact of global budgeting in Taiwan on inpatients with unexplained fever Keh-Sen Liu, Tsung-Fu Yu, Hsing-Ju Wu, Chun-Yi Lin Medicine.2019; 98(37): e17131. CrossRef
What happened to health service utilization, health care expenditures, and quality of care in patients with acute pancreatitis after implementation of global budgeting in Taiwan? Ya-Lin Ko, Jyun-Wei Wang, Hui-Mei Hsu, Chia-Hung Kao, Chun-Yi Lin Medicine.2018; 97(41): e12620. CrossRef
The impact of global budgeting on health service utilization, health care expenditures, and quality of care among patients with pneumonia in Taiwan C.-Y. Lin, T. Ma, C.-C. Lin, C.-H. Kao European Journal of Clinical Microbiology & Infectious Diseases.2016; 35(2): 219. CrossRef
Comparison of Hospital Standardized Mortality Ratio Using National Hospital Discharge Injury Data Jong-Ho Park, Yoo-Mi Kim, Sung-Soo Kim, Won-Joong Kim, Sung-Hong Kang Journal of the Korea Academia-Industrial cooperation Society.2012; 13(4): 1739. CrossRef
Predictive Ability of Charlson Comorbidity Index on Outcomes From Lung Cancer Apar Kishor Ganti, Emily Siedlik, Alissa S. Marr, Fausto R. Loberiza, Anne Kessinger American Journal of Clinical Oncology.2011; 34(6): 593. CrossRef
Comparative Study on Three Algorithms of the ICD-10 Charlson Comorbidity Index with Myocardial Infarction Patients Kyoung Hoon Kim Journal of Preventive Medicine and Public Health.2010; 43(1): 42. CrossRef
The Impact of Medicaid Expansion to include population with low income on the preventable hospitalizations Hyun-Chul Shin, Se-Ra Kim Korean Journal of Health Policy and Administration.2010; 20(1): 87. CrossRef
Charlson Comorbidity Index as a Predictor of Long-Term Survival after Surgery for Breast Cancer: A Nationwide Retrospective Cohort Study in South Korea Hye Kyung Woo, Jong Hyock Park, Han Sung Kang, So Young Kim, Sang Il Lee, Hyung Ho Nam Journal of Breast Cancer.2010; 13(4): 409. CrossRef
A comparison of the Charlson comorbidity index derived from medical records and claims data from patients undergoing lung cancer surgery in Korea: a population-based investigation Hyun-Ju Seo, Seok-Jun Yoon, Sang-Il Lee, Kun Sei Lee, Young Ho Yun, Eun-Jung Kim, In-Hwan Oh BMC Health Services Research.2010;[Epub] CrossRef
Health Outcome Prediction Using the Charlson Comorbidity Index In Lung Cancer Patients Se-Won Kim, Seok-Jun Yoon, Min-Ho Kyung, Young-Ho Yun, Young-Ae Kim, Eun-Jung Kim Korean Journal of Health Policy and Administration.2009; 19(4): 18. CrossRef
Factors Affecting Health of the Rural Residents Dong-Koog Son, Kyu-Sik Lee, Jong-Ku Park, Sang-Baek Koh, Ki-Nam Jin, Eun-Woo Nam, Hae-Jong Lee Korean Journal of Health Policy and Administration.2009; 19(4): 1. CrossRef